Bethel worked back into the match over the middle quarters. Megan Williams scored with 3:58 remaining in the second quarter to trim the deficit to 5-4, and Ella Vick tied the game at 5-5 just 35 seconds into the third. Madonna answered immediately in the possession battles that followed. Conrad put the Crusaders back in front 6-5 on another man-up goal at 8:30 of the third, this time assisted by
Ri O'Connor, then added another goal at 2:46 off an assist from
Marissa Rushlow for a 7-5 lead entering the fourth.
The Crusaders finished with a 25-21 edge in shots and put 18 attempts on goal, while also committing fewer turnovers, 22 to Bethel's 29. Bethel controlled more draws, 12-5, but Madonna made better use of its extra-player chances and completed 20 clears. Turner added a goal and an assist for Madonna. In net,
Olivia Vitantonio made eight saves on 21 shots faced, helping preserve the lead as Bethel pressed late. Bethel goalkeeper Maddie Reel kept her team within reach with 10 saves.
Bethel made one final run in the fourth quarter, getting a free-position goal from Williams at 7:29 to cut the lead to 8-6, then a goal from Mackenzie Holland with 2:11 left to make it 8-7. That left Madonna needing one more defensive sequence, and the Crusaders got it, surviving the final minutes to secure the narrow win.