FARMINGTON HILLS, Mich. - Caiden Thomas kicked a 27-yard field goal with 15 seconds remaining to complete a 21-point comeback as Madonna University (4-7) defeated Defiance College (OH) (3-8) 37-35 on Saturday, Nov. 14, in Farmington, Mich. The Crusaders scored the final 23 points to end the 2026 season and senior day with a win.
Seniors recognized before the game were: Mohammad Berro, DJ Dandridge Jr., Reese Pulliam, J.J. Lamphere, Colin Tola, Christian Wynn, Cooper Koenigsknecht, Aiden Dupuis, Carson Hines, Reese Greenfelder, Jonathan Rentrope Jr., James McMahon III, Andres Rugel, Ernesto Caballero, Rodney Francois, and Jonathan Edwards.
Kolter Smith connected with Micale McClure for a 65-yard touchdown on Madonna's first offensive play, but Defiance answered with 28 consecutive points. Chris Cotton's 11-yard touchdown run tied the game before Amariyan Glover returned a fumble 52 yards for a second-quarter score. Cotton then found Mar'Kel Wade for a 25-yard touchdown on fourth-and-10, and Marshawn Taylor's five-yard scoring run sent Defiance into halftime ahead 28-7.
Smith hit McClure for an 18-yard touchdown on third-and-12 early in the third quarter. Cotton answered with a 71-yard touchdown pass to Taylor, restoring the 21-point margin at 35-14 with 10:33 left. Even after Nehemiah Bailey intercepted Smith at the Defiance 3, Madonna kept pushing. Demetrick Welch's 30-yard run helped fuel a 70-yard drive that ended with Welch catching a seven-yard touchdown pass with 16 seconds remaining in the quarter.
McClure's third touchdown reception, a 16-yarder on third-and-10, brought Madonna within 35-28 with 11:44 left in the fourth quarter. Lemuel Pettway intercepted Cotton at the Madonna 43 with 8:17 remaining, setting up Smith's 12-yard touchdown pass to Rodney Francois at the 5:09 mark. Holding nullified a successful extra point, and after a false start, the subsequent attempt failed, leaving the Crusaders trailing 35-34.
Madonna's defense forced a three-and-out, giving the offense possession at its own 25 with 3:23 remaining. A 28-yard completion to JoJo Brothers helped move the Crusaders into kicking range. Thomas finished the 11-play, 66-yard drive with the winning field goal, giving Madonna its first lead since the opening quarter.
Smith finished 24-of-42 passing for 328 yards and five touchdowns with one interception. McClure caught eight passes for 159 yards, while Welch added 74 rushing yards on 16 carries and 34 receiving yards on five catches. Madonna outgained Defiance 378-331, converted eight of 15 third downs and scored on all five trips into the red zone.
Brock Culpepper led the defense with 13 tackles, including 5.5 for loss and one of Madonna's five sacks. Tahsaan Lunn and Blake Zoro each contributed seven tackles and a sack as the Crusaders held Defiance scoreless in the fourth quarter. Defiance gained 13 yards on two completions during its final possession, with Culpepper tackling Jadynn Martin after a 10-yard catch as time expired.
Madonna Football finishes the 2026 campaign with an overall record of 4-7 which shows the immense improvement and effort from last season.